Thanksgiving is the North American holiday that celebrates the family, and the Thanksgiving dinner is the main event of the holiday. For some reason I had never contemplated preparing a Thanksgiving dinner, perhaps because we were never home on Thanksgiving. Well this year we were here and I felt ambitious enough to tackle the turkey -- the center piece of a classic Thanksgiving dinner.
Incidentally, the best Thanksgiving turkey I had, was oddly from a far-away place not normally associated with Thanksgiving dinners, namely the restaurant at Hotel Plinio in Manual Antonio, Costa Rica. We were both just recovering from a case of Montezuma's revenge, and were tentatively opening up our appetite. The restaurant was famous for its small plates and that was what we went for. We had forgotten the day was Thanksgiving day, and the restaurant was only serving Thanksgiving dinner. So we shared one order, starting with a delish pumpkin soup, followed by a huge plate of turkey, stuffings, and all sorts of fixings. Everything tasted so perfect, and yet the two of us with our delicate stomaches couldn't even finish half of the plate. We felt very tragic. Maybe it tasted even better because of our inability to enjoy it more -- what we cannot have, we always dream of more...
With that idealized turkey dinner in my mind (although I've long forgotten how exactly it tasted, or even what was in the stuffing), I start to work on my own. My first task was to buy a bird that is small enough for my dinner party (or four people) and would not produce so much leftover to last until...xmas. Luckily I found one at Whole Foods labeled at 7.3 lbs, and it was not even frozen so I did not have to thaw it. Then I started in search of a recipe, from my various cookbooks as well as a zillion choices on the web, I tried to formulate my own approach. My sister gave a couple of tips: brine the turkey, and cook the stuffing separately.
The big day dawned. I still had quite some shopping to do -- all I had at the moment was the turkey, which I put in a brine. I was in for a terrible shock as I pulled in my first shopping stop -- the parking lot was deserted, the store closed. I had not taken it for granted that stores would open on any given day, after all, the Chinese groceries are open on Chinese new year. But not all stores are so practical -- some chose to let their employees have a life. Luckily, my third stop was open, and bustling. It was not without problems though -- half of the things I wanted was sold out! Almost in panic mode now, I tried to concentrate on the positive and congratulated myself on my wise act I of getting the turkey early... After another 3 stores, each lacking some items I was seeking, my shopping list was finally almost filled. I shall remember this lesson well, if I ever make a holiday dinner again, DO NOT LEAVE SHOPPING TO THE LAST DAY!
I was planning to make a pumpkin pie (another staple). What I did not count on was that it would take quite a long time to prepare, as I learned from the expert (Matthew's mom) at the last minute. So no pumpkin pie for us. Another lesson learned (hopefully).
Anyway, the rest of the dinner plan went without incident, and the turkey was cozily tucked into the oven as we played a boardgame, sipping sangria and enjoying the aroma from the kitchen. Thanksgiving was cozy! Everything went without a glitch until the turkey came out of the oven. I sat it on a plate to steep in its own juice. The next minute, as I was ready to make the gravy, I couldn't find the turkey drippings (the main ingredient of the gravy)! My overly zealous dishwasher (a person who shall not be named here)had already washed the tray! Needless to say he incurred my greatest wrath, and hurriedly offered to squeeze the last juices out of the turkey. So our gravy was mostly chicken, with just a touch of turkey (can anyone really tell?).
The dinner was a success! (if I do say so myself) The turkey was tender, to my relief, although not quite as tasty as I hoped, and nothing to compare to that idealized memory, but was descent enough. The star of the dinner was the mushroom and chestnut stuffing (recipe attached). Matthew's squash also receive good reviews.
Here's the stuffing recipe (modified slightly from an online one):
Ingredients:
1/2 loaves old-fashioned white bread, cut into 1/2-inch cubes (or equivalent amount of dried cubed toast)
generous amount of butter (+ olive oil) [I used my leftover sage butter from my turkey rubbings: butter+sage+pepper+salt)
1 onion, chopped
1/2 pound mushrooms, sliced
a couple of celery stalks, chopped
a medium sized carrot, chopped
3/4 pound fresh (or frozen) chestnuts, roasted, shelled, chopped
a couple of sprigs of fresh thyme leaves
a sprig of chopped fresh rosemary
dash of ground nutmeg
about 1/2 cup chicken broth
dash of dry Marsala [optional]
Directions:
[Skip this part if using dried toast] Preheat oven to 400°F. Divide bread between 2 large baking sheets. Bake until golden, stirring occasionally, about 25 minutes. Transfer to large bowl.
Melt butter in heavy large skillet (with olive oil, if using) over high heat. Add onions and cook for a few minutes. Reduce heat to medium. Add mushrooms; stir until mushrooms begin to soften and release juices, about 5 minutes. Add celery and stir 2 minutes. Mix contents of skillet into bread cubes. Mix in chestnuts, thyme, rosemary and nutmeg. Season to taste with salt and pepper. Mix in chicken broth to moisten. Add a dash of Marsala.(Can be prepared one day ahead. Cover and refrigerate).
Spoon stuffing into buttered baking dish. Cover stuffing with buttered aluminum foil. Bake stuffing in a dish alongside turkey until heated through, about 45 minutes. [alternatively you can stuff the stuffing (at room temperature) into the turkey before the turkey goes into the oven]
1/2 loaves old-fashioned white bread, cut into 1/2-inch cubes (or equivalent amount of dried cubed toast)
generous amount of butter (+ olive oil) [I used my leftover sage butter from my turkey rubbings: butter+sage+pepper+salt)
1 onion, chopped
1/2 pound mushrooms, sliced
a couple of celery stalks, chopped
a medium sized carrot, chopped
3/4 pound fresh (or frozen) chestnuts, roasted, shelled, chopped
a couple of sprigs of fresh thyme leaves
a sprig of chopped fresh rosemary
dash of ground nutmeg
about 1/2 cup chicken broth
dash of dry Marsala [optional]
Directions:
[Skip this part if using dried toast] Preheat oven to 400°F. Divide bread between 2 large baking sheets. Bake until golden, stirring occasionally, about 25 minutes. Transfer to large bowl.
Melt butter in heavy large skillet (with olive oil, if using) over high heat. Add onions and cook for a few minutes. Reduce heat to medium. Add mushrooms; stir until mushrooms begin to soften and release juices, about 5 minutes. Add celery and stir 2 minutes. Mix contents of skillet into bread cubes. Mix in chestnuts, thyme, rosemary and nutmeg. Season to taste with salt and pepper. Mix in chicken broth to moisten. Add a dash of Marsala.(Can be prepared one day ahead. Cover and refrigerate).
Spoon stuffing into buttered baking dish. Cover stuffing with buttered aluminum foil. Bake stuffing in a dish alongside turkey until heated through, about 45 minutes. [alternatively you can stuff the stuffing (at room temperature) into the turkey before the turkey goes into the oven]
Happy Thanksgiving!